I'd like to also help out with suggestions on who would be suitable to being a Mentor. Firstly, I'll present a list of players I think would best serve as Mentor. Then, I'll give a description in terms of the positive aspects those players have and their qualifications. Finally, I will present my opinion towards the nominations made by other players as to help with the selection process.
A. Player Nominations (in alphabetical order)
Josephdm - Like Cooster said, although Joe is a newer member of our community, he has shown great enthusiasm in server matters such as advertising and pitching new ideas. Further, Joe's work ethic is shown in him helping new players, instructing them on how to register, and tips on how to play on our server. He is well versed in our server rules, and he seems like a very promising player.
Motorthud - Moto is a very friendly player who consistently greets new players and helps them start off. He is also quite active in server events and city-building, as shown by his involvement in Caledonia, like previously stated by himself. Though it would be great to see him on just a bit more, he maintains strong connections to our players formed throughout his time with us.
Riccardo164 - I'd also like to nominate myself for the role of Mentor. Given my long-standing relationship with BossSMP and its players since mid-summer of 2011, I've developed friendships with many of our players. I am also proud to say that I am probably one of, if not the most active player among Citizens, Donators, and even some Mods, and as such, I keep a good check on server affairs and player activities. In addition, I carry an extensive knowledge of the server rules, server history, and player commands/plugins, providing guidance to players and sometimes helping out staff on deciding matters. I also have a frequent presence in the Forums and Tickets sections, further cementing my connection to server issues. One can see just by asking some players that many of our regular players started off with my tips and outstretched arm, and have developed into well-standing members of our BossSMP society.
B. Opinions on Other Nominations (as to help the deciding process run fairly and quickly)
While it is very important to acknowledge the qualifications of our nominees, it is equally necessary to take into account some issues regarding other nominees.
On darkkiller - Though I respect Darkkiller as a player and will recognize some of Dark's achievements such as presenting the idea of a Caledonia hotel, there are many faults with his nomination. First of all, Dark does not maintain a steady, ongoing attendance in the server and in the Forums. It can be noted that Dark sometimes abruptly leaves the server for an unknown amount of time without giving prior notice. Also, Dark has minimal Forum activity, not visiting or maintaining the Forums unless advertising a personal project. I would also like to note Dark's poor mannered language, as evidenced by his unfriendly and off-putting commands delivered during the ongoing construction of the Caledonia hotel project. Further, I will challenge motorthud's conjecture that Dark helps out new players. Not once during my tens of hours a week, have I seen Dark giving any new player direction or tips on playing or registering.
On furrybunny101 - Maintaining poor server attendance and an average knowledge of server workings, furrybunny selection to Mentor would further the notion of a server valuing "cute" over hard work. Howsoever one views her positivism, one can see the minimal effect it would help a job on Mentorship without a strong knowledge of rules and policy. In addition, her pull to working on personal projects such as Wool-art in Creative and the past Hunger Games map greatly mars her duty as a Mentor to help new players over working on her own constructions. Lastly, one can measure her inactivity by simply doing a /seen or even seeing how long after her promotion would she log on. Inactivity is one of the greatest difficulties in maintaining a high-attendance job such as Mentor.
With that said, I hope I did not sound demeaning to the aforementioned two players darkkiller and furrybunny101, but simply note their inability to support such a large role in the server. I would also strongly urge the hardworking staff to consider my nominations as well as my opinions on why some nominees are unfit to carry the role of Mentor.